Set up consultation
Leading the Way in Automotive Innovation

Future Mobility Index

What is the Future Mobility Index?

The Future Mobility Index is a comprehensive tool designed to evaluate and compare vehicles based on critical criteria that define the future of mobility. Developed by H&Z, this index provides valuable insights into the sustainability and efficiency of modern vehicles, helping stakeholders navigate the complex automotive market.

The Four Pillars of the Future Mobility Index

Energy Efficiency

Measures the energy consumption of vehicles, accounting for propulsion methods and overall efficiency

Volume Efficiency

Evaluates the use of recycled materials and the vehicle’s overall circularity ambition

Circularity

Implement initiatives and build procurement capabilities.

Price

Balances cost against performance and sustainability to provide a comprehensive value assessment

Explore the best ranking Vehicles

The following table brings together all vehicles analysed to date and provides an overview of how each one performs across the different categories, along with an overall total score.

RankModelVersionEnergy EfficiencyVolume EfficiencyCircularity AmbitionPrice AttractivenessTotal Score
1Renault Mobilize DuoL79386409584
2Renault TwizyIntens9389209581
3Microlino Medium Range-9077208475
4VW ID. Every1-10035408673
5Citroen AmiAmi808109971
6SAIC-GM-Wuling Bingo-8634010062
7Firefly EV-843009259
8Hyundai InsterStandard Range7342208159
9Dacia SpringEssential Electric 45744708958
10Fiat 500eHatchback774507357
11Mini Cooper Electric-7340207157
12Fiat Grande Panda ElektroRed7530208056
13Nissan Micra ElectricStandard Range (40 kWh)7532207556
14Lancia Ypsilon54 kWh7336207056
15Renault 5 E-Tech ElectricTechno7235207155
16Renault Scenic E-Tech Electric170 Comfort Range68134010055
17BYD Dolphin SurfActive753208254
18Mini Aceman Electric-7232206954
19Alpine 290_ßTurbo753106351
20BYD DolphinComfort6923207151
21Opel CorsaElectric703706951
22Volvo EX30Single Motor6722406351
23Citroen e-C3You 113673008250
24Ford Puma Gen-E-762406650
25Kia EV3Standard Range7219206750
26VW ID. 3Pro7122206950
27VW ID.3Pure7122206650
28VW ID. 3Pure7122206650
29Alfa Romeo JuniorElettrica712906349
30DS N°4E-Tense7222205649
31Fiat 600e-712806749
32Hyundai Kona Electro-7318206149
33Tesla Model 3 (Highland)RWD761706048
34Volvo EX30Single Motor6722206348
35Cupra Born-6522206147
36Opel Frontera-6415207547
37Tesla Model 3Highland (Hinterradantrieb)761606047
38VW ID. 7Pro S754404147
39Abarth 500e-662406546
40BMW i4eDrive357215204346
41Mercedes EQA2507311205146
42Opel Astra ElectricElectric702106146
43Renault ZoeZE50 R110662706646
44Skoda Elroq50697207046
45Smart #1Pure6416206946
46Zeekr XCore RWD6616206446
47BMW iX1eDrive207110205445
48BYD Atto 2-691207345
49Chery Omoda 5E5701606345
50Volvo EX30Performance 4WD6622205045
51VW ID.4Pure686206245
52Kia EV6-688205544
53Kia EV6Standard Range 2WD686205744
54Mini Countryman Electric-669205944
55Opel GrandlandElectric GS750204944
56Polestar 4Long Range Single Motor650603844
57Skoda Enyaq60713205844
58Skoda Enyaq85724205344
59Smart #3Pro661706544
60VW ID.7 TourerPro744204644
61Audi A6 Avant e-tron-737203543
62Audi Q6 e-tron-690403643
63Audi Q4 e-tron40685205643
64Cupra TavascanEndurance717204443
65MG S5 EVComfort Standard Range68906543
66Tesla Model Y (Juniper)Long Range AWD720204843
67Tesla Model YRWD700205743
68Audi Q4 e-tron45685204842
69BYD SealDesign681305742
70BYD SealRWD Design681305742
71Mercedes EQE350+693402742
72Ford CapriER RWD72405041
73Opel GrandlandElectric Standard Range670205541
74Xpeng P7RWD Long Range671005241
75Smart #5Pro630205640
76Smart #5Pro+630205039
77VW PassateHybrid65705139
78Xpeng G6RWD Standard Range66005938
79Changan Deepal S0762863005737
80Lucid AirPure RWD74901237
81Polestar 3Long Range Single Motor620401937
82VW ID. BuzzPro (NWB)620203937
83Porsche TaycanSport Limousine671020036
84Porsche MacanElectric670201736
85Vinfast VF 8Eco Extended Range580204836
86VW ID.BuzzPro langer Radstand610203736
87Xpeng G6AWD Performance65005036
88BMW i5 TouringeDrive40610202635
89Zeekr 1Long Range RWD64003935
90Audi e-tron GT quattro-65820034
91Mercedes EQE SUV300640201334
92Kia EV9RWD590202633
93BYD Yangwang U9-65120032
94Hyundai Ioniq 5 N-561202332
95Lotus Emeya-65020032
96Volvo EX90Single Motor600201332
97BMW iXM70 xDrive58020029
98Lotus Eletre-56020028
99VW Tiguan1,4 eHybrid25605921
100VW GolfLife028207621

How is the Future Mobility Index Calculated?

The H&Z Future Mobility Index provides a comprehensive rating system for cars and other means of transport based on four pillars of future mobility. The methodology behind the index ensures an objective, data-driven evaluation of how a specific is contributing to the future of mobility.

 

Core Evaluation Criteria

Each vehicle in the index is assessed across four categories to ensure a holistic view of sustainability and customer value. Each category is rated and the maximum score a vehicle can reach is 100. For clarity, numbers are rounded. 

How much energy is needed to transport a person? The life cycle CO2 emissions of a vehicle are defined by the energy it needs for driving – outnumbering emissions from production by far. Hence, we use the rated WLTP consumption (including charging losses for battery electric vehicles) adjusted by actual vehicle occupancy to derive our score. For combustion-engine vehicles, we convert the litres of diesel / petrol consumed into their kWh equivalent to allow comparison.

How much volume is covered to transport a person? On average, a car driven in Germany is occupied by 1.46 persons. Hence, we calculate the vehicle body’s volume (simplified as a rectangle) and divide it by 1.46 to come to the volume occupied per person transported. Volume efficiency is the single most important driver of traffic jams, scarce parking and a proxy for resource intensity in production.

How circular is a vehicle? Already today, vehicles can be recycled to very large shares of their weight. The same is true for battery electric vehicles where recycling processes are increasingly efficient and available at scale. With circularity ambition, we go a different route. We assess the amount of secondary materials going into a vehicle. In this assessment, we rely on information published by the OEMs.

How expensive is a vehicle? Any form of mobility must be affordable for its users. This is why we include the undiscounted sales prices for the German market at the time of market introduction in the Future Mobility Index. Over time, prices are not adjusted for inflation, and we exclude any OEM-granted rebates.

How Are the Scores Determined?

The H&Z Future Mobility Index scores are calculated based on publicly available data published by the vehicle OEMs. For each score, we define upper and lower bounds between which a linear regression is applied to differentiate between scores in the range.

Our Latest Insights

In Automotive, we deliver measurable savings, stronger supply chains, and lasting organisational capabilities.
All H&Z Insights
Report cover mockup titled "EU Automotive Supplier Crisis: what needs to be done today?" featuring various automotive parts like gears and tools, representing a white paper on supplier profitability and crisis management in the European automotive industry
Study
01.10.2025

Explore cutting-edge strategies for automotive suppliers to overcome historic profitability challenges and enhance financial stability.

Two consultants collaborating at a whiteboard, brainstorming and sketching diagrams during a strategic planning workshop, representing collaborative consulting sessions.
Article
18.09.2025

Discover how to boost engineering efficiency by up to 35% with five strategic levers that drive innovation and meet customer demands.

Recap
09.09.2025
 | Munich

At our IAA Mobility Breakfast, experts discussed sustainability, electrification, supply chains, and tech trends shaping the mobility industry.

Mockup of a strategy paper titled ‘Acting upon regulation GB38031-2025’ featuring an automotive assembly line photo on the cover, addressing how companies should prepare for China’s battery safety regulation; beige background design underscores compliance and procurement strategy.
Strategy Paper
22.08.2025

China’s new regulation sets the global benchmark for EV battery safety. Act fast to secure compliance and market access.

European Union and United States flags on small stands in front of a car production line with robotic arms.
Article
06.08.2025

The new 15% tariff on EU car exports demands that OEMs adapt strategically to maintain competitiveness and restructure their operations.

European Union and United States flags on miniature stands in a warehouse filled with boxes, symbolizing transatlantic trade negotiations, tariffs, and procurement logistics strategies in consulting.
Article
06.08.2025

The recent 15% tariff demands procurement leaders reassess sourcing strategies and enhance operational agility to navigate a changed landscape.

Why the Future Mobility Index Matters

The Future Mobility Index is not just a tool for evaluating individual vehicles; it provides insights into broader market trends, helping companies, investors, and policymakers make informed decisions. Whether you’re looking to compare vehicle classes, analyse market shifts, or understand the competitive landscape, our index can offer clarity.

Let us help achieve your objectives

Our experts combine consulting excellence with deep industry experience to deliver results that last.

Dr. Albert Neumann

Partner
Dr. Albert Neumann is a Partner at H&Z and an expert in the automotive industry, focusing on corporate strategy, R&D, and integrating sustainability through digitalisation and circular economy approaches​.

Tobias Stahl

Principal